If people prefer more for both sides to less for both, everyone should select the plan giving both sides more. In a 2018 CCES highway choice, only 35.0% of Democrats and 27.1% of Republicans did so; the rest chose smaller allocations that left their side ahead. In a post-election experiment, raising opponents’ income gain from 3% to 7%, while keeping the own-party gain at 5%, changed policy support by -20.0 points on a 0–100 scale (95% CI [-23.9, -16.1]). Relative partisan gains affect support, but the exercises do not distinguish spite from dislike of falling behind; the highway comparison also changes total spending.
Cite: Gaurav Sood and Alexander G. Theodoridis. "Pareto Partisan? Relative Gains and Support for Public Policy." https://gsood.com/research/pareto-partisan-relative-gains-and-support-for-public-policy/
BibTeX:
@misc{soodpareto,
author = {Gaurav Sood and Alexander G. Theodoridis},
title = {{Pareto Partisan? Relative Gains and Support for Public Policy}},
note = {Working paper},
url = {https://gsood.com/research/pareto-partisan-relative-gains-and-support-for-public-policy/}
}