← Meta Science › Miscitations

We compare each of 8,627 retracted research articles, published 2000–2019 and retracted 2005–2022, with up to five articles from the same journal and publication year matched on pre-retraction citations, using OpenAlex citation histories through 2025 for both. In the three complete years after the retraction year, citations to retracted articles were 62% lower than the path of their comparison articles implies, and the gap keeps widening for a decade. Retracted articles nonetheless continue to be cited: across 8,963 retracted articles, 27% of all citations arrived after the retraction year, five years on 39% of the articles observed that long were still being cited, and in a hand-coded sample 91% of post-retraction citations noted no concern with the cited article.

Cite: Gaurav Sood and Ken Cor. "Propagation of Error: Citations to Retracted Research." https://gsood.com/research/propagation-of-error-approving-citations-to-problematic-research/

BibTeX:
@misc{soodpropagation,
  author = {Gaurav Sood and Ken Cor},
  title = {{Propagation of Error: Citations to Retracted Research}},
  note = {Working paper},
  url = {https://gsood.com/research/propagation-of-error-approving-citations-to-problematic-research/}
}